Finding the best laptop bags: A buying guide

carrying laptop or tablet

 

Best laptop bags: how to find durability, safety, and style

by Tablets for Artists

Finding the best laptop bag for your lifestyle doesn’t have to be a chore. But there are a lot of things to consider before taking the plunge. You want a bag that’s going to last and serve your needs for a long time to come.

Many of us carry a laptop as well as a tablet. So the best laptop bag for digital artists should have certain features, chief among them a dedicated laptop compartment or pocket, and a dedicated tablet compartment or pocket. These should be padded.

Laptop and tablet sizes are measured diagonally and referred to by screen size. So a 15” laptop would fit into a computer bag of 15” or larger. Most laptops are 13.1″ to 15″. 17″ is fairly common too, and some are 19″. There are netbooks that are much smaller. Tablets come in many sizes, but 7″, 8″, and 10″ are common. Some bags specifically state computers that will fit into them; it doesn’t mean that other computers won’t, but customers could be searching for a bag for their MacBook Pro.

pelican computer case

The Pelican 1495 Black Computer Case is a hard-shelled briefcase with protective foam inside.

A waterproof pouch on the inside to protect your electronics is a useful feature. Extra outer pockets for books and magazines, paper notebooks/ work items, an e-reader, water bottle, and other sundries are a good addition.

There are laptop bags you carry over your shoulder; backpacks; rolling backpacks; cross-body bag, e.g., messenger bags; roller bags with two or four wheels (spinners); pocketbook styles; and briefcases. There should be room for chargers, headphones, external hard drives, and the like. A very small container can be handy for small electronics that get lost easily, such as SD cards, USB sticks, batteries, and other small personal items. Photographers who don’t want to carry a separate camera bag would also look for a pocket to carry a DSLR and lenses. Especially handy for artists are small pockets for pens and styluses and pockets for extra nibs.

Does the bag’s style match its purpose? You probably don’t want to go to the office with a bag that looks like you’re going hiking, even if the hiking bag is one of the best laptop bags there is.

Are the zippers well made?  Lockable zippers–ones that have ports that allow you to add a luggage lock–are important.

A rolling bag takes the weight off you. Spinner bags have four wheels instead of two. They are easier to maneuver, but can be hard to control. Their wheels take up extra space. Roller bags tend to have cutouts for the wheels and the wheels tend to be larger.

 

Delsey rolling bag for laptops

This Delsey Luggage Helium Aero spinner has an external compartment that gives you quick access to your laptop and helps speed you through airport security. See it on Amazon.

victorinox laptop roller bag

 

victorinox trevi

This Victorinox Trevi Laptop Brief is a (pricey) example of a two-wheeled bag specially made to accommodate a laptop. It’s got pockets galore! Victorinox is considered one of the best luggage brands.

Many bags come in different colors and sometimes patterns.

While most bags are unisex, there are laptop bags specifically aimed at men or women, mostly based on style.

Your bag should be structured and firm, but offer some flexibility.

For a tablet, you will want a soft sleeve or hard case to keep your screen safe in the tablet compartment of the bag. For a laptop, if the pocket is larger than your computer, you may want to use a sleeve to keep the computer from moving around too much in transit, as moving toward the sides of the bag can increase any impact on the device. A tablet or laptop should fit snugly into the pocket. Some bags have straps to secure devices.

Art tablets. For a graphics tablet like an Intuos that doesn’t have a screen to scratch, you can get away without an extra sleeve if the bag has enough padding. Some art tablets, particularly the older Cintiqs, have a large amount of gear you need to carry to power them. Make sure your bag can accommodate the necessities. At the very least, wrap your 13HD in a t-shirt and put it in the middle of soft clothing so there are inches of clothes around it. The larger-size Cintiqs and other large display tablets are generally better off in a hard-shelled roller bag with a sleeve, plenty of extra cushioning and optionally, a box or hard case. If you still have it, you could use the box and packing material the tablet came in.

Being TSA-compliant is a timesaver for travelers. This popular Timbuk2 messenger bag has a TSA- compliant outer laptop sleeve. You can open it up flat with your laptop showing and easily remove your laptop. It also has a tablet sleeve.

timbuk2 messenger tsa

Weight is an important consideration. Get something that doesn’t add too much weight to the gear you’re putting in it, but not something flimsy or nonsecure.

When online shopping, you can’t try putting your laptop in. So if you’re unsure your computer will fit, you can contact the manufacturer. Remember to take the thickness of your computer or tablet, sleeve included, into account when fitting a bag.

Sometimes bag companies seem to forget to add product images of the inside. More images can be often be found on the company’s Web site or you may need to download or request a catalogue.

Back support is important to remember when looking for the best laptop bag. It can be hard to carry a laptop around even for fairly short periods if you have back pain, and it can make back pain worse or even cause it. So the part next to your back should be strong but flexible. The straps should also be padded, comfortable, and easy to adjust.  A chest strap is good if you will be carrying a heavy load and want added support. A waist strap can also add support and take some load off your spine.

If you’re going to be carrying the bag by hand, choose a bag with extra fabric on the carrying handle or a smooth, rounded carrying strap. Your hand can feel cut up from carrying a heavy bag.

Not enough little pockets? If your bag is missing some of these features, you can buy an organizing grid to increase your packing options. We love this Cocoon Grid-it Organizer for the little things. It not only straps things into place, it has a zipper pocket to keep more items. If you have a lot of chargers they won’t get tangled up together. (It does take a bit of work to arrange things this artfully).

 

best laptop bags grid-it organizer

See the Cocoon Grid-it Organizer on Amazon.

There are many things to keep in mind when choosing from the best laptop bags.

Do you want an open bag, such as an over-the-shoulder type, to easily take out your laptop/tablet, or do you want to keep it zipped or buttoned? One without a zipper or buttons is much less secure and open to pickpockets. But it might be OK for indoors, such as walking around an office, or for quick errands. Still, keep the device in a sleeve.

What is the bag made of? Bags come in many materials. Polyester is popular and easy to clean. There’s also leather, both real and synthetic, both of which protect from water; thick cotton canvas; neoprene, and hemp. Protection is accomplished via padding, air cells, or elastic slings. Obviously, the hard ones can handle more impact. But your laptop and tablet needs to be protected from the hard sides themselves, so they should be put in a sleeve.

Zippers should be strong and sturdy. It’s preferable if they have a loop to make them lockable. The zipper should not have jagged teeth, which can hurt your hands while opening and closing the zipper—I had that happen with one bag. Be sure that the zipper is in good condition when you first get your bag, and that any buttons, and clasps are securely attached. Broken zippers and falling buttons can make your bag less useful and less attractive. Magnets can be good closures, but be careful to not leave magnetized cards around them, as the cards can get demagnitized.

What’s around you? Consider your environment. Will the bag see rough weather? Would you be using it often? Would you fly with it as a carry-on personal item? Will you be biking, hiking with your laptop? If you’re going to get sweaty, getting breathable fabric with padded straps tha have mesh is optimal. If you’re going to school and will also be carrying books, be mindful of back strain. If you’re a parent, when purchasing a bag for a child, be sure it’s not going to be too heavy, and be careful of how much goes into it.

Will you be in crowded spaces such as trains? If so, you might want one with a slender profile and/or a handle on top to avoid banging into people. As well, many museums will let you carry your backpack in only by hand, so if you’re an art lover you may want a bag that’s not so long it or parts of it would drag on the ground, and a top handle helps. This Dakine Mission backpack is slender and the straps cleverly form a back handle.

best laptop bags dakine mission

How tall are you? You don’t want to be dwarfed by your bag. And you don’t want a bag that fits tightly.

Do you want to carry other things besides your digital equipment? If so, you might want a weekend bag type of laptop carrier, one with room for some clothing and other items. Using it for work? You might want there to be a sleeve that can carry folders. You might want to check the specs to make sure you can put folders in the way you want. Horizontally is best, so your papers can face up.

Many bags have some padding, but the best laptop bags have ample padding on the bottom as well, as that part of the bag is likely to receive some knocks no matter how careful you are. If the bag does not have a lot of padding, use a padded laptop sleeve. You might want to use one at all times even if the bag is padded; however, if the pocket is both well-padded with a cushioned interior and firm exterior, your laptop should be safe for every day carrying.

Some of the best laptop bags offer advanced security, antitheft, and safety features. These can include zippers that lock, cut-proof shoulder straps, cut-proof fabric, lockable compartments, reflectors, secret pockets for your passport, and RFID blocking. Safety features can include a reflector and loops to attach carabiners, a flashlight, and a whistle. Having an accessible pocket for your cell phone is both a convenience and a safety feature.

As well, some have small, fleece-lined pockets for cell phones and glasses or ski goggles.

osprey backpack for laptop

 

This Osprey Quasar laptop backpack offers many antitheft features, including RFID, which stops thieves with electronic readers from being able to read your credit card numbers.

We hope this has covered the basics of what you need to know to find the perfect laptop bag to be your travel companion–so go ahead and compartmentalize.

end of Finding the best laptop bags: a buying guide

 

Video: how to use Intuos Draw and ArtRage for a portrait

https://youtu.be/GuhtGTeN76Q

In this video by Wacom Americas, artist Barbara Leitzow shows how to use the oil paint tools in ArtRage to paint a portrait using the Intuos Draw. ArtRage is an affordable digital painting program with tons of fun features, such as brushes that look like real oil paint, and even glitter (can’t go wrong with glitter). If you don’t want to sink the money into expensive digital art software at this time, ArtRage is a great place to start (and you may even decide to continue with it)–it has mobile and desktop (Mac and PC) versions. The program supports Wacom features such as Tilt and Rotation, and even has settings for various Wacom styluses. It has layers and blending modes, and you can choose different canvas textures. ArtRage gives you a lot of control and customization abilities. It’s optimized for touch, with a lot of tools on-screen. It gives you the ability to mirror and duplicate strokes. The interface is simple and intuitive. It’s as easy as drawing with crayons.

NVIDIA Shield 2 reported for 2016: gaming tablet, Dabbler art app

NVIDIA Shield 2 gaming tablet powers its own painting app

NVIDIA Shield 2 gaming tablet reportedly coming in 2016 keeps the Dabbler art app

nvidia shield tablet

NVIDIA Shield Tablet

As you may or may not have heard, the popular NVIDIA Shield Tablet (see on Amazon) was recalled last year because of battery problems (the battery was a possible fire hazard). Customers with the recalled units could get a free replacement. The NVIDIA shield has a fast Tegra processor and has been marketed primarily as a gaming tablet; however, Nvidia makes its own art app, Dabbler, that took advantage of its graphics acceleration to offer effects such as realistically-dripping paint. The stylus is the NVIDIA  DirectStylus 2.

nvidiashielddirectstylus

The pressure sensitivity in the NVIDIA SHIELD is not like Wacom, N-trig, or Synaptics. It’s not even an active digitizer at all. Rather, the processor can read how hard you’re pressing the rubber tip of the Direct Stylus. And it actually works, though not quite to the level of a real active digitizer. Still, it’s a pretty darn good sketchbook. Dabbler’s effects menu includes drawings, watercolors, and oils.

Here’s a video of the NVIDIA Dabbler art app with Direct Stylus 2.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G7JJqM8oMYQ

Now, reports are saying that a sequel is coming out, the Nvidia Shield 2. Like the original, it will run on Android and have the latest Tegra processor, the Tegra x1. It will have an 8″ display.  THe battery life for non-gaming is said to run 10 hours, with half that for gaming. The rumored list price will be $299. (The original is still for sale in two sizes and prices on the NVIDIA site.) You’d also be able to use other Android art apps.

If you have one of the NVIDIA Shield Tablets facing recall and have not yet returned it to NVIDIA, go to this page on their site that has info about the recall.

best tablet PC

Surface Pro 4 Review: a step (or 1,024) forward

Surface Pro 4 Review: a go-anywhere drawing solution

by Tablets for Artists

microsoft surface pro 4 with surface pen

Type of Tablet

Surface Pro 4 Review: Convertible 2-in-1 with pen

The Surface Pro 4 and Surface Book (read our review) have arrived on the scene to a great deal of fanfare. Some artists who already have a Surface Pro 3 may be wondering if it’s worth getting the 4. Others may be trying to decide between the SP4 and the pricier Book.

The SP4 can become a laptop when you add the optional (purchased separately) Type Cover; it’s a tablet-first device, whereas the Book is a laptop-first device. The Pro 4 and the Book have the same screen resolution, a very high 271 ppi, though the Book’s screen is larger. Both the SP4 and Book are built from magnesium alloy and come in just one color, a silvery gray, though the SP4’s Type Cover adds a splash of color, with 6 colors. Only the Onyx (black) has the fingerprint sensor, though, to give you that Get Smart cred.

UPDATE: There have been many reports of short battery life and other issues and this takes a bit of glow off the Surface Pro 4 review, which would otherwise be very positive. The last updates issued by Microsoft were Dec. 2 and Dec. 17, which fixed some issues but not the power management. They did suggest a workaround, which you can read here, which is to put it into hibernate instead of sleep mode. Also, Windows Hello facial recognition drains the battery  and may be to blame for the issues. You can say bye-bye to Hello by turning it off in Settings> Accounts > Sign-in options. Will be following these issues and updating further.

UPDATE #2: Microsoft issued a Surface Pro 4 and Surface Book firmware update on Jan. 27, 2016. This one improves battery charging, Bluetooth, and the fingerprint sensor. Apparently it improves the sleep bug (the battery drain issue) but does not completely fix it. You should receive a notification on your device, and follow instructions. They should automatically install, but if you’re doing it manually, go to Settings > Update & Security > Windows Update > Check for updates and follow the steps.

UPDATE #3: Microsoft released a slew (16!) updates in April, 2016, which apparently have corrected issues with screen flickering and waking up from sleep or hibernation, and other issues. Guess the early adopters were really beta testers. Anyway, it’s considerably improved. Note that they do not install all at once after you update.

List of updates at the Microsoft update page.

Specifications

Windows 10 Pro
Display: 12.3″
Digitizer: N-Trig
Screen Resolution: 2736 x 1824 pixels (271 ppi)
Processor: 6th-generation Intel Core i5; i7; entry-level model has Intel Core M3
RAM:  4 GB, 8GB, or 16GB
Hard Drive: models with 128 GB, 256 GB, 512 GB, and1 TB
Ports: one USB 3.0, MicroSD slot
Core M3 model is fanless; others have hybrid cooling system
Kickstand allows posing at any angle
Glass trackpad 40% larger than SP3
8 MP rear camera, 5 MP front (SP3 had 5MP for both)
new Surface Pen and nib kit included
Pen has 1,024 levels of pressure sensitivity
graphics are all integrated, no discrete
Keyboard has fingerprint sensor (only the Onyx/black color)
weight 1.76 lbs. (786 g) tablet only; 2.44 lbs. including Type Cover and pen

What’s in the Box

Surface Pro 4
Surface Pen
Power Supply
Quick Start Guide
Safety and warranty documents

Surface Pro 4 vs. Surface Pro 3

As you can see, the Surface Pro 4’s screen is a bit bigger; its screen resolution is quite a bit higher, and it still manages to be a little lighter. Microsoft’s PixelSense screen is a mere 400 microns thick and uses Gorilla Glass 4; the Surface Pro 3 used Gorilla Glass 3 and did not have PixelSense, which pushes the optics closer to the screen. The footprint is the same on the SP4 and SP3, as is the 3:2 aspect ratio, which resembles a sheet of drawing paper. This aspect ratio, which emulates the Golden Mean, is generally better to draw on than the 16:9 tablets. The pen now magnetically snaps to either side of the tablet, instead of using a pen loop.

There is also no Start button on the tablet bezel in the SP4; there was in the SP3, but it’s less useful in Windows 10.

Here is a Surface Pro 3 vs. Surface Pro 4 comparison chart.

FeaturesSurface Pro 4Surface Pro 3Difference
Dimensions11.5 by 7.93 by 0.33 inches11.5 x 7.93 x 0.36 inchessame
Thickness8.5 mm SP3 9.1SP4: 7% thinner
Screen size12.3"12"SP4: 5% larger
DigitizerN-trig, 1,024 levels of pressure sensitivity N-trig, 256 levels of pressure sensitivitySP4: 4x as pressure-sensitive
Resolution2736 x 1824
(4,990,464 pixels)
2,160 x 1,440
(3,110,400 pixels)
SP4: 60% more pixels
Screen ppi (pixels per inch)271ppi213 ppiSP4: 27% denser
ProcessorIntel gen. 6 Intel gen. 4SP4: 30% faster
Weight (tablet only)1.69 lbs, 767g - Core M
1.73 lbs, 786g - i5 and i7
1.76 lbs, 798 gSP4: slightly lighter (4% for Core M, 2.5% for Core i5and i7)

 

surface pro 4 review

Surface Pro 4 with Surface Pen

The Surface Pro 4 with i5 with 128 or 256 GB of flash storage would be fine for most artists who use Photoshop or the whole Adobe Suite. But if you use really resource-intensive programs, then the i7 is better. For instance, Autocad 3D requires the i7.

The Book has an option with dedicated NVIDIA GeForce graphics, good for gaming or getting a boost in Photoshop performance.

Battery Life

9 hours of video for the 8GB Ram i5 with 256 GB storage

Portability

At 1.76 pounds, it’s very portable. If you add on the Type Cover (.64 lbs./292 g) and pen (21 g) then you get about 2.43 lbs., still not a bad load.

 

Surface Pen

surface pen surface book

The new Surface Pen for Surface Pro 4 (see it on Amazon) snaps to the sides of the tablet via magnets, unlike the Surface Pro 3 and earlier Surfaces which had a pen loop. The pen is much improved, now enabling 1,024 levels of pressure sensitivity. Not only that, but it has its own nib kit , which has 4 tips that simulate artist pencil leads of HB (preinstalled), H, 2bB B, and a fine-point pen. The nib kit does not come with the pen that comes with the tablet. You can buy it separately (it’s inexpensive) or, if you buy an additional pen, the kit is included. The pen that comes with the Surface Pro 4 has a silver barrel, but the additional pens come in other colors.

The pencil leads have some friction and give some bite, somewhat like drawing on paper. Another boon is that you can buy a nib kit if your nibs wear down or get lost. The pen also has an eraser tip that feels cushiony. The previous pen had two buttons, one of which activated the eraser, but this new one has just one, which can open OneNote or Cortana, or take a screenshot if you double-click the button. Microsoft says the new pen has reduced latency–perhaps it won’t go into sleep mode when not touching the screen, so will be faster. The digitizer is N-trig, connected by Bluetooth, and takes an AAA battery that Microsoft says lasts a year. The pen itself (the barrel, not talking about inking) comes in 5 colors.

surface pen nib kit

new Surface Pen nib kit

Compare this to the previous Surface Pen, which delivered 256 levels of pressure sensitivity. Its single, preinstalled nib would wear out quickly and was not replaceable, forcing you to buy another pen. So if you’re ready to buy one, the new Surface Pen is the right choice. The new pen is backward compatible with the Surface Pro 3, though you’d still get 256 levels of pressure sensitivity, not the 1,024 of the Surface Pro 4 or Surface Book.

For some images and discussion of drawing with the Surface Pro 4 pen, and a comparison with Wacom pens, please see this review of the Surface Book. Here’s an image of the line from one of the pen tips. You can change the canvases as well as the brushes in your art program to get different effects with the different tips.

While this is cool, there are many, many brushes available for Photoshop and you can get any effect. Depending on your screen, though, you might not get the little “bite” of friction that the pencil nibs offer.

.surfacepentiptestBtip

 

Type Cover

surface pro 4 type cover

Surface Pro 4 Type Cover

The Type Cover has been redesigned and is also backward-compatible with Surface Pro 3. It has dedicated buttons for Windows shortcuts, media controls, and screen brightness. The Type Cover comes in 6 colors, and is lighter and slimmer than its predecessor. The keys are now spaced apart and have better travel for faster and more comfortable typing. The keys are sturdier than on the last version, and the keyboard has a better magnetic connection to the tablet part. The trackpad with 5-point multitouch is 40% larger, and now made of glass. You can fold back the cover so you can still use the tablet while it’s connected, or fold it over the tablet to protect the screen. The keys are backlit.

Only the Onyx (black) Type Cover uses Windows Hello, a fingerprint ID system that lets you log in to the computer and shop in the App Store. It costs a bit more than the non-fingerprint ID Type Covers (there is also a non-fingerprint-ID Onyx Type Cover). The Onyx fingerprint Type Cover can be pre-ordered from the Microsoft Store here.

surface dock for surface pro 4

Surface Dock

Surface Dock

The Surface Dock is optional. It can be used with the Surface Pro 3, Surface Pro 4, and Surface Book. It provides two additional ports: four USB 3.0 ports, and two 4K-capable DisplayPort outputs. The slender Surface Book lacks an Ethernet port, but the dock provides one. This can come in handy when traveling in places without steady Wi-fi.

Pros

new Surface Pen and nibs
faster processor
many configurations
hybrid cooling system (or fanless on the Core M) quieter

Cons

Still not ideal as a laptop replacement, due to top-heaviness
Opinions divided on N-trig

The Verdict

If you like N-trig, then this is a very promising computer with great specs for speed, a display that’s high-resolution with high contrast for deep blacks, lightweight, and it can do double duty as a laptop, though the Type Cover doesn’t feel as solid as a traditional laptop. For now, though there are still battery drain issues to be fixed, the workaround should provide release. Even taking that into account, this Surface Pro 4 review is mostly positive, and this sleek machine opens a new chapter in the Surface Pro story.

See more info or order from the Microsoft store

 

The iPad Pro is a competitor to the Surface Pro 4. Read our iPad Pro review.

end of Surface Pro 4 review

microsoft surface book review

Microsoft Surface Book Review: a laptop-first 2-in-1

Microsoft Surface Book Review: Solid laptop, detachable art tablet

by Tablets for Artistsmicrosoft surface book review

 

See it on Amazon.

See it at the Microsoft Store.

UPDATE: Many users have had a short battery life and other problems. Microsoft last issued and update on Dec. 2 and 17th,  but the power management has not been addressed. Their suggested workaround, is to not use sleep mode, where the battery drains, but rather hibernate. Windows Hello may be the core of the problem.. You can say good-bye to Hello by shutting it off in Settings> Accounts > Sign-in options.

UPDATE #2: Another firmware update has been released for the Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 on Jan. 27, 2016. This one is for Bluetooth, battery, and fingerprint sensor, but though the battery drain issue anecdotally is better, it’s still there. To see more about updates, check this page on Microsoft’s site.

Type of tablet

2-in-1 convertible

Specifications

Magnesium build, including keyboard
Windows 10 Pro
12.30” x 9.14” x 0.51 – 0.90” (312.3mm x 232.1mm x 13.0 – 22.8mm)
Screen: 13.5” PixelSense display
Resolution: 3000 x 2000 (267 PPI)
Aspect ratio: 3:2
1700:1 contrast ratio gives you deep blacks
10 point multi-touch
Two USB 3.0 ports
SD card reader
Surface Connect (an 80-pin connector)
Mini DisplayPort
Solid state drive (SSD) options: 128GB, 256GB, 512GB, or 1TB
5.0MP front-facing HD camera
8.0MP rear-facing camera
Dual microphones (front and back); Dolby speakers
Starting at 2.34 lbs. (1,516 grams) including keyboard base
Glass trackpad with 5-point multitouch
Backlit keys
Intel Iris processor on the i7
4.5 lbs. with keyboard, 1.6 lbs. for clipboard (tablet) only
Power and volume buttons on clipboard (tablet)

The camera on the Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 is compatible with the Hello Windows facial recognition software that lets you use your face instead of saying “Swordfish” (or typing in a password) The Book does not have a fingerprint reader, so you can’t log in that way; only the fingerprint-reader model of the Onyx SP4 Type Cover does.

Graphics

i5: Intel HD graphics 520
i5/i7: Custom NVIDIA GeForce Graphics Processor

The discrete graphics are in the keyboard case, so when you detach the keyboard, the Book will switch back to regular integrated graphics, which are strong enough to do most things, but if you are using 3D programs and the like, you would need to flip the screen over and keep the keyboard on.

What’s in the box

Surface Book and keyboard
Surface Pen
Quickstart guide
Safety/warranty documents

Screen

The Gorilla Glass display is super sharp, with 6 million pixels at 271 ppi (same ppi as in the slightly smaller Surface Pro 4, which has about 5 million pixels). Microsoft claims it will get the entire sRGB color gamut. The blacks are deep. The screen is 12.3 inches wide, and 13.4″ diagonally, with a small bezel. Its 3:2 aspect ratio is intentionally made to the proportions of a standard A4 sheet of paper. The screen is 21% larger than on the Surface Pro 4.

Portability

At about 3.4 lbs. including the keyboard and pen (pen weighs 21 g or about three-quarters of an ounce), it would start to feel heavy after carrying it around for a short time–maybe consider a rolling laptop case. The clipboard (tablet) without the keyboard weighs 1.6 lbs, quite light.

Battery Life

12 hours video with keyboard attached
3 hours with screen only (4 hours without video)

Microsoft says then when the lid is down, the battery will not drain.

To draw and get the longer battery life, you can remove the screen then flip it around and re-attach it to the keyboard so the screen is facing up. (see Update above for notes on widespread battery drain issues)

Call me Clipboard. Microsoft is calling the tablet part of the computer the “clipboard,” lest you forget to think of the Surface Book as a laptop. It’s first a laptop, second a tablet. Got it?

Good-bye, pen loop. The pen now snaps to either side of the clipboard via magnets.

 

The “dynamic fulcrum” hinge

microsoft surface book review 2

The innovative accordian-like hinge that Microsoft calls “dynamic fulcrum” gives a rounded edge, making it more comfortable to hold in your palm than a rectangular edge. When shut, there is a small gap between the keyboard base and screen. The hinge uses a wire dubbed “Muscle Wire” as part of the sinew that holds the two halves together. The hinge is strong and you can pick up the whole device by the keyboard or display. You can also open the Book to any angle. The Surface Book does not have the stand attached to the back that the Surface Pro line has, so if you want to prop up the tablet, er, clipboard, alone, you will have to use an exterior stand.

One Microsoft Surface Book review found that having the gap between the keyboard and clipboard was a problem when carrying it in a bag–dust and dirt would end up on the keyboard. So storing it in a laptop sleeve might be a good idea.

surface book muscle wire

Muscle Wire

 

 

 

 

 

 

surfacebookconnector

 

To detach the clipboard, you press a button on the keyboard. If you’re using the Nvidia graphics, which will cease to work once you take off the keyboard, you will see a notification.

surfacebookdetach

You hold down a key on the keyboard for a couple of seconds until you see this pop up. You will get another message when you have successfully attached it. The detaching/attaching process is not super simple.

Microsoft calls it a “continuum” when you take the clipboard off to continue using it.

Trackpad

surfacebooktrackpad

Surface Book trackpad

The large, glass trackpad with 5 touch points feels great on the fingers–it’s smooth and responsive, like skating on ice.

When in laptop mode, you cannot open up the whole thing flat the way you can with a regular clamshell laptop. So if you’re drawing, you either need to somehow draw with the clipboard up, or switch to tablet mode, which gives you no access to the keyboard. You can’t use the keyboard base unless it’s attached. So if you want to use keyboard shortcuts, you will need to use the on-screen keyboard, a USB or Bluetooth keyboard, or try some Photoshop actions.

Despite the Surface Pro being laptop-first, when in laptop mode the clipboard wobbles  a bit. The keyboard base and the tablet are roughly equal in weight, but it seems it would balance better were the screen considerably lighter than the keyboard. However, it isn’t too bad.

New Surface Pen

surface pen surface book

Blue Surface Pen. The one that comes with the Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 is silver.

The new Surface Pen is a great improvement over the old. First of all, it now has 1,024 levels of pressure sensitivity (after Microsoft spent some time assuring us that 256 was fine and most of us agreed). It’s still N-trig (Microsoft has purchased the technology behind N-trig, so it’s here to stay, and it’s nice to see them improving it with artists in mind). There’s  now a cushiony eraser on the back. The pen has only one button now; the previous pen used one of the buttons to activate an eraser. You can click to open OneNote or double-click to take a screenshot and put the image into OneNote.

Best of all, the pen comes with 4 nibs, including artist pencil nibs of 2H, H, HB, and H, and a fine-point pen. HB is the preinstalled tip. The nibs have some friction, giving some tooth to the drawing experience so it feels more like paper. The old pens did not come with extra nibs, the nibs didn’t last long, and there was no way to replace them; you had to buy a new pen. The pen takes one AAAA battery. Microsoft says this pen will have reduced latency (less lag). Testing it, it still has some lag, perhaps a bit less than the SP3. The pen has a solid heft to it.

 

surface pen nib kit

Pen tip kit

Because of the replaceable nibs, this new pen should last much longer; it’s more economical and less wasteful. If your nibs wear out or get lost, you can buy an extra nib kit. It’s backward-compatible with the Surface Pro 3 (with which you would still get 256 levels of pressure sensitivity) and will also work with the Surface Pro 4 (which gives you the full 1,024 levels). Microsoft claims the pen has a full year of battery life. The pen barrel comes in five colors– charcoal, blue, red, silver and gold. The Surface Book and Surface Pro 4 come with the pen, but not the nib kit, which is inexpensive. If you buy an additional pen, that pen will come with the nib kit.

Surface Pen nib test

surfacepenhbnib

HB pencil on smooth canvas in Fresh Paint

surfacepennib

B tip on smooth canvas in Fresh Paint

surfacepro4pencil

B tip on rough canvas in Fresh Paint

The B tip does look more like a pencil line. You can choose a brush that says, say, 4H and still use the 2B pencil, which I find a little hard to wrap my mind around. Every brush you choose will look a bit different with the different nibs.

Writing with the Surface Pen is not bad, but isn’t quite as natural as on paper–harder than with Wacom, but easier than using an iPad with a basic capacitive stylus.

When using the eraser tip, the eraser size doesn’t adjust in OneNote, it wipes out a large area, but in art programs it’s adjustable.
The issue with slowly-drawn diagonal lines being wavy is still there, and it’s just a function of the digitizer and the rate at which it “polls” the data. There are some ways to fix it, such as using Lazy Nezumi or a line smoother such as in Manga Studio. Or just draw lines more quickly. There is a definite and palpable improvement with the new pen and increased pressure levels. To me, N-trig is still not as satisfying as Wacom to draw with but it’s not because of the jitter. However, many artists really like N-trig. It’s best to try it out. The Surface Book is an ambitious concept and I hope we see more laptop-first tablet PCs with detachable tablets as these are ideal for drawing.

Surface Dock

surface dock for surface book

The Surface Dock doesn’t come with the Surface Book or any computer. It’s not necessary for everyone, but is useful. It sports two 4K-capable DisplayPort outputs and four USB 3.0 ports. It also has an Ethernet port, which the Book itself lacks.  The dock is compatible with the Surface Pro 3, Surface Pro 4, and Surface Book. (There’s a different dock that works with the SP 1 and 2.)

Pros

fast (Microsoft claims that with the discrete graphics, it’s effectively twice as fast as the MacBook Pro)
improved pen
larger screen
wide color gamut
1700:1 contrast ratio gives deep blacks
very high-resolution display (267 ppi vs. MacBook Pro’s 232)

Cons

pricey
heavy with keyboard attached
a bit top-heavy
dirt can get onto keyboard when closed due to gap (suggest keeping it in a sleeve)

The Verdict

This is a powerful computer, though it has been marred by some battery-charging issues.  you’re trying to decide between this and the Surface Pro 4 and primarily want it for drawing, you would probably be fine with the Surface Pro 4, which has an improved keyboard. The i5 Surface Pro 4 is considerably cheaper than the i5 Surface Book.

If you want a more solid keyboard, a larger drawing surface, or if the discrete graphics are important to you, then the Surface Book would be the way to go. It also is just nice-looking. It certainly could be a solution to the artist who wants a laptop too.

If you’re interested in the history of PixelSense tech, here it is on Wikipedia.

See more Microsoft Surface Book reviews, price, and info on Amazon

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVfOe5mFbAE

End of Microsoft Surface Book Review

See our Microsoft Surface Pro 4 review.